When you’re choosing an auto insurance company, it’s easy to focus on price or brand familiarity. But what really matters is how your insurer shows up when you need them most: During a claim.
Each year, more than 1,100 collision repair professionals across the country share their perspectives on the insurers they work with every day. Their feedback offers a unique, behind-the-scenes perspective that most drivers wouldn’t otherwise have access to.
In the 2026 report, Frankenmuth Insurance earned a place among the top 20 auto insurers in the nation and was named to the Insurer Report Card Honor Roll, with an overall grade of “B.” This recognition demonstrates our commitment to delivering a dependable claims experience. Accidents are stressful enough — our goal is to make the process as smooth and straightforward as possible.
A strong claim experience starts with choosing the right partner. Talk to a local, independent agent about what sets us apart — and how we’ll be there for you when it matters most.
