Let’s have a frank conversation.

Make a Payment

There are several ways to make a payment. Choose what works for you.

Let’s face it: Mail delivery is not as timely as it used to be. And there’s nothing worse than paying a late fee or having your policy canceled due to something out of your control.

At Frankenmuth Insurance, we want you to have control of your account and prevent late fees and cancellations from happening in the first place. That’s why we provide several convenient ways to make a payment, including this website, our mobile app, recurring payments via EFT or credit card, or you can call in a payment during business hours. We still accept payment by mail, too.

Credit cards can be used for one-time or recurring payments. We accept MasterCard, VISA, and Discover. For security purposes, please do not submit credit card information via email or fax. If you would like to set up recurring EFT payments, please complete the authorization form below with your banking information. Options for submitting this information are detailed on the form.

Online and Mobile:

Pay online through our password-protected program. You can pay by EFT or credit card. Online and mobile payments through Frankenmuth Insurance are safe and save time.


Call 844-488-9777 to pay over the phone by EFT or credit card. Our billing representatives are here to help Monday – Friday, 8 a.m. – 5:30 p.m. EST.


Email your completed EFT Authorization Form to [email protected].


Fax your completed EFT Authorization Form to 989-652-9222.


Premium payments sent by check or money order will be applied to the account the day they are received. Please allow adequate mail time. Mail your check or money order to:

Payment address:

Frankenmuth Insurance
P.O. Box 88762
Chicago, IL 60680-1762

Correspondence address:

Frankenmuth Insurance
1 Mutual Avenue
Frankenmuth, MI  48787-0001

Overnight address:

Frankenmuth Insurance
1 Mutual Avenue
Frankenmuth, MI  48734-0001